Case studies / Insurance agency

An Allstate Agency Lifted Lead Connections from 1.8% to 28% with LeadChaser

28% of purchased leads connected by phone in April 2025, against a 1.8% insurance industry average

At a glance

28%lead connection rate, April 2025
1.8%insurance industry average
1,905leads connected with the agency
166,207automatic calls placed

The challenge

An Allstate insurance agency buys opt-in leads from a third-party vendor, the way most agencies do. The problem is what happens next. The standard connection rate for purchased insurance leads is about 1.8%: for every 100 leads the agency paid for, fewer than two ever turned into a phone conversation. The rest went cold while the agency kept buying more.

The approach

BusySeed put the agency's lead lists, including older leads everyone had given up on, into LeadChaser. Every lead was called as soon as it arrived, leads that did not pick up got a personalized text sequence, and the system kept calling back on a schedule instead of relying on an agent to remember. Interested leads were connected straight to the agency's team.

The results

  • 28% of purchased leads connected by phone in April 2025, against a 1.8% industry average
  • 26% connected in October 2026, on 592 new leads
  • 1,905 leads connected with the agency from 11,741 purchased leads, March 2024 to November 2026
  • 166,207 calls and 135,811 texts placed automatically
  • An average of 8.5 calls to reach a lead, which the system made on its own
  • 58% of conversations came on call five or later, leads most agents would have given up on
  • The agency has renewed since 2024, scaling from 200 leads a month to as many as 1,000

Source: LeadChaser account records for the Allstate agency, lead statuses grouped by month of arrival, March 2024 to November 18, 2026. LeadChaser was built by BusySeed. Read this case study on BusySeed.

Your leads are next.

Start with 20 free credits and see what your own numbers look like.

Start free, no card